It's not enough to have multiple endings in a video game to make it feel like a satisfying conclusion to the hours you'd just spent making your way there. There's a real art to constructing an ending, and throwing three options you can click your way to with one button doesn't suffice.
Of course, you don't need multiple options to make an ending feel like a proper resolution. It just so happens that Silent Hill 2—TAY contributor DanimalCart's vote for best ending—goes that route.
You can read DanimalCart's case for Silent Hill 2 Best Ending Ever down below but, of course, be wary of spoilers.